Is It a Bag or a Hollow? Why Your Under-Eyes Look Tired

Illustration showing how a falling cheek creates a hollow under the eye that can look like a bag, beside an inset of a true bag where fat behind the eye bulges forward.

By Dr. Keswani, MD — Forever Medspa & Wellness Center

“I have bags under my eyes.” It’s one of the most common things people tell me. Very often, though, there’s no bag at all. What they’re seeing is a hollow. The difference matters, because hollows and bags have different causes and very different treatments. Some can be helped in the office. Others can’t, and I’d rather tell you that honestly than sell you something that won’t work.

How the eye area is built

The eyeball sits in a bony socket. Small pockets of fat cushion it, and a thin sheet called the orbital septum attaches to the bone around the socket and holds that fat back. In front of the septum is the eye muscle, the orbicularis oculi.

Below the eye sits the cheek. Deep fat pads next to the cheekbone (the SOOF, or suborbicularis oculi fat) support the cheek. On the inner side, the eye muscle and septum attach to the bone. That attachment separates the lower lid from the cheek, and it’s the line many people see as the tear trough.

Hollows that look like bags

With age, and with repeated weight loss and weight gain, the deep fat that supports the cheek shrinks. Fat lost there isn’t regained in the same place. The cheek falls a little and pulls the lower-lid skin down with it.

Now the gap between the lid and the fallen cheek looks continuous with the eye. Because the eye area is big and round, people read that shadow as a bag. But there’s no bag in it. This is the part filler can actually correct: giving back support deep in the cheek lets the lower lid sit higher again.

True bags: fat behind the eye

True bags are different. The fat around the eyeball sits behind the septum, and the weight of the eyeball pushes it forward. As the socket gets a little bigger with age and the septum and muscle loosen, that fat bulges out over the lower edge of the bone. There’s nothing behind it but that thin septum.

Some people have these bulges from a young age, because their socket is a little larger and there’s more of a gap between the eyeball and the bone. It isn’t only an ageing change. The cheek can still fall later on top of that, and that part can be helped.

Fat can’t be removed without surgery. Radiofrequency treatments can tighten the skin, muscle and septum and push bulges back to some extent, but they don’t remove fat.

Puffiness that comes and goes

Then there’s swelling. The eye area drains slowly, so more salt, more fluids or a night’s sleep can mean puffiness in the morning. Sometimes it shows in the upper outer cheek, just below the outer corner of the eye; when there’s a lot, it’s called malar mounds. Any medical condition that makes you retain water makes it worse. It isn’t something filler causes, though filler placed too superficially in that area can cause the same kind of swelling.

A simple way to tell the difference: fat bags look the same all day and don’t change with salt or water. Puffiness comes and goes.

When the eyes bulge: thyroid eye disease

In thyroid eye disease, such as Graves’ disease, an autoimmune process enlarges the tissue behind the eye and pushes the eyes forward. That’s a medical condition, and it has to be treated first. Treating it often reduces the bulging. If a lot of fat remains afterward, that needs surgery.

The press test

In the office, I use a simple check. I gently press the cheek just below the hollow and push upward. If the hollow improves, filler can help, and what you see while it’s pressed is a rough preview of the result. If it’s a crease that doesn’t improve when pressed, filler won’t help it, and I won’t force filler into it.

Talk it through with us

The right answer depends on what’s actually there: a hollow, fat, swelling or a mix. That’s what a consultation is for. You can read more on our Eye Area page, text us at (201) 340-4809 with your questions, or book a consultation online. Current offers are always on our Promotions page.

med24

med24